Time Travel found four archives of the nymag website. Three out of the four worked, but not the web.archive.org site (The Internet Archive Wayback Machine). Considering the sensitivity of the topic (Comey saying he was a Commie; probably just a joke but these days I just might take it seriously) and my experience with the Wayback Machine and other sensitive topics, Is the Wayback Machine comp'd? because, in my experience, it often can't or won't pull up a citation that should be there or maybe it "hides" it. The Time Travel website just proved that.
Also, notice that an archive.is website shows up as archive.md.
