https://twitter.com/nberpubs/status/1407428176696025088/photo/1

From JUNE 2021

The Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic and Policy Responses on Excess Mortality

Virât Agrawal, Jonathan H. Cantor, Neeraj Sood & Christopher M. Whaley
WORKING PAPER 28930 DOI 10.3386/w28930 ISSUE DATE June 2021

As a way of slowing COVID-19 transmission, many countries and U.S. states implemented shelter- in-place (SIP) policies. However, the effects of SIP policies on public health are a priori ambiguous as they might have unintended adverse effects on health. The effect of SIP policies on COVID-19 transmission and physical mobility is mixed. To understand the net effects of SIP policies, we measure the change in excess deaths following the implementation of SIP policies in 43 countries and all U.S. states. We use an event study framework to quantify changes in the number of excess deaths after the implementation of a SIP policy.

We find that following the implementation of SIP policies, excess mortality increases. The increase in excess mortality is statistically significant in the immediate weeks following SIP implementation for the international comparison only and occurs despite the fact that there was a decline in the number of excess deaths prior to the implementation of the policy.

At the U.S. state-level, excess mortality increases in the immediate weeks following SIP introduction and then trends below zero following 20 weeks of SIP implementation. We failed to find that countries or U.S. states that implemented SIP policies earlier, and in which SIP policies had longer to operate, had lower excess deaths than countries/U.S. states that were slower to implement SIP policies. We also failed to observe differences in excess death trends before and after the implementation of SIP policies based on pre-SIP COVID-19 death rates.

https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w28930/w28930.pdf